2017-06-25

26: To Beware of Harmful Rhetoric, Part One

<The previous article in this series   The next article in this series>
Main body START

Everybody? Really? Nobody? Really?

-Hypothesizer

They say, "Everybody says you are a freak."

-Rebutter

They? Who are 'they'?

-Hypothesizer

The bullies.

-Rebutter

So, bullies really inhabit the Bias planet. How do they look like?

-Hypothesizer

Well, their shapes aren't particularly different from those of normal humans.

-Rebutter

Really? Don't they have horns or pointed ears?

-Hypothesizer

No, they don't.

-Rebutter

Hmm, that's trouble. Aren't there some features by which we can discern bullies?

-Hypothesizer

Well, they usually show mean facial expressions.

-Rebutter

How mean?

-Hypothesizer

It's . . . terribly mean.

-Rebutter

I don't understand.

-Hypothesizer

It's difficult to describe.

-Rebutter

Do they always exhibit their terribly mean faces?

-Hypothesizer

Unfortunately, no. They usually look as though normal humans, but suddenly, they metamorphose their faces so that you will be transfixed by horror.

-Rebutter

It's too late if we discern bullies then. Aren't there other features?

-Hypothesizer

This isn't about looks, but they use words such as 'everybody', 'all', or the like wantonly.

-Rebutter

As in "Everybody says you are a freak."?

-Hypothesizer

Yes. They are their party pieces. "Everybody hates you"; "Everybody wants you to die"; "All the Muslims are terrorists"; "All the females are inferior"; you name it.

-Rebutter

In reverse expressions, there are expressions like "Nobody likes you"; "Nobody wants you to live"; "No Muslim is peaceful"; "No woman is competent"; you name it.

-Hypothesizer

I won't have to name more.

-Rebutter

Are you the one who was told "Everybody says you are a freak."?

-Hypothesizer

Well, . . . yes.

-Rebutter

As we are an extraterrestrial, I don't particularly deny that we are a freak, at least according to some Earthians' standards, but it's doubtful whether 'everybody' says so. In fact, most Earthians don't know even the existence of us. How can everybody say so? Who is 'everybody'?

-Hypothesizer

Maybe, the ones who said so and a few others, or maybe some dozens. It doesn't seem to mean everybody on the Bias planet, the country, the city, the class, or whatever. 'Everybody' is the members of their group, how large it is; it's their world; somebody outside their group isn't included in 'everybody'.

-Rebutter

So, for them, people outside their group just don't count.

-Hypothesizer

I understand how using 'everybody' wantonly is a typical symptom of being bully. They happily divide the others from them, and don't have any scruple about the others, who are nobody at all.

-Rebutter

Ah, the so-called 'Us versus Them' mentality.

-Hypothesizer

Bullies are, in many cases, good people in their own group: they are popular and even kind, sympathetic, or whatever in their own group.

-Rebutter

It's the same with a boss of a gang: he or she is popular in the gang; otherwise, he or she wouldn't have become a boss. Regrettably, it's also the same with democracy: someone is or at least can be elected by promoting benefits of a group and bullying the others.

-Hypothesizer

Someone might say that 'everybody' is just rhetoric, but it's very harmful rhetoric!

-Rebutter

What the rhetoric says is that somebody who isn't included in 'everybody' isn't worth consideration. That's the purpose of the rhetoric.

-Hypothesizer

The baseness of rhetoric users is that they are ready with the excuse, "It was just rhetoric."

-Rebutter

If that excuse is allowed, they can get away with saying anything.

-Hypothesizer

Can't rhetoric be prohibited?

-Rebutter

Among Earthians? There is no possibility. Earthians love rhetoric.

-Hypothesizer

I know, . . . it was just rhetoric.

Another mean aspect of that kind of use of 'everybody' is that they don't claim things on his own reasoning and responsibility: they take 'everybody''s name in vain!

-Rebutter

Well, certainly, that will be another motive of using 'everybody'.

-Hypothesizer

The root of the problem is that they lack the attitude to pursue truths. Being true is being accurate. To be able to say "Everybody does . . .", one has to first confirm that each one really does so without exception. To say such a thing without verification is insensitive. Such insensitivity to accuracy sickens me!

-Rebutter

Congregations to the bullies! Their intention is to sicken you.

-Hypothesizer

Well, I seem to be duck soup.

Main body END

<The previous article in this series   The next article in this series>